When Bad Publicity Becomes Good Marketing: Why Brands Are Embracing Controversy

I’m always a little fascinated by how much thought goes into making a brand appealing. The carefully chosen colours, the polished adverts, the pretty packaging and the promise that whatever it’s selling will somehow improve your life. Then there are brands that seem to have taken an entirely different route, making a point of being obnoxious, deliberately divisive or even downright irritating.

And somehow, people keep talking about them. A post that gets shared, screenshotted and fought over travels way further than an advert that gets scrolled past, which is why some brands have made provoking people a deliberate marketing decision rather than an accident.

 

Nobody Argues About An Advert They Scrolled Past

 

Brands have always competed for consumers’ attention, but now a campaign sits in the same feed as creators, memes and someone’s holiday photos, with a few seconds to earn a pause. Social platforms also let one post travel beyond the audience that follows the brand, since reposts, quote posts and screenshots carry it into feeds that would never have seen it otherwise. Even an angry reply can introduce the original post to a whole new audience.

That’s the logic behind brands that aren’t chasing universal approval. A company doesn’t need everyone to love a campaign; it needs the right people to recognise themselves in it and it can usually live with the rest rolling their eyes.

 

Liquid Death Made Water Look Like A Heavy Metal Gig

 

Water is about the least exciting product a brand can sell, which makes Liquid Death’s approach delightfully ridiculous. It put water into tall aluminium cans that look like beer tallboys, added a skull logo and built a personality around dark humour and slogans like “Murder Your Thirst”, so the whole thing feels closer to a heavy metal merch stall than a drinks aisle. I’m someone who can be won over by a perfume bottle before I’ve even tried the scent, so I’m hardly in a position to judge anyone for paying extra because of the container something comes in.

The founder, Mike Cessario, previously worked as a graphic designer for advertising agencies and according to Fortune, the company reached a $1.4 billion valuation in March 2024 after a $67 million funding round. Cessario told the magazine that its valuation had doubled and its revenue had tripled since 2022, crediting the brand’s irreverent online presence as a major part of its growth.

 

 

Ryanair Treats Complaints Like Content

 

Ryanair has built a recognisable online personality around sarcastic replies, confrontational humour and a willingness to poke fun at its own reputation. Its social media presence doesn’t exactly follow the usual customer-service handbook, which is part of what makes it so distinctive.

A 2025 study by researchers at Vienna University of Economics and Business analysed 4.5 million words of tweets posted by and addressed to the airline between October 2020 and March 2023. The research examined how Ryanair combined aggressive humour with commentary on socio-political issues, finding that its approach fuelled heated discussions and divided its audience. Some people appreciated the humour, while others were far less impressed.

The researchers also found that this approach could encourage greater engagement, with users frequently commenting on and discussing the airline’s posts. Their paper was titled “Mocking people for stupid opinions is not fun. Also it’s bad for business”, which is quite a headline for a study about an airline’s social media strategy. It also makes the point that getting people talking isn’t necessarily the same as getting them on side.

 

Nike Didn’t Need Everyone In The Room

 

Nike’s 2018 Dream Crazy campaign was a different kind of controversy, because nobody was telling a joke. The brand put Colin Kaepernick, the former NFL quarterback who became a divisive figure after kneeling during the national anthem to protest racial injustice and police brutality, at the centre of its 30th anniversary Just Do It campaign. People posted videos of themselves destroying their Nike gear and calls for boycotts followed, along with criticism from President Trump. Nike’s shares fell by around 3% on the first trading day after the campaign was announced, before reaching a record high ten days later.

Edison Trends, which analysed online shopping receipts from more than three million Americans, found that Nike’s online sales rose 31% between the Sunday and Tuesday of Labor Day weekend in 2018, compared with a 17% increase over the same days in 2017.

Taking a side isn’t free, though. A 2020 study in the International Journal of Research in Marketing found that brand activism significantly lowered brand attitudes among people who disagreed with a brand’s position. There was also a marginal improvement among supporters when a brand faced public backlash for its position. That lopsided response helps explain why taking a side can be a risky move, even when a brand believes it has the right audience.

 

Burger King’s Tweet Needed A Different First Line

 

Burger King UK found the other side of all this on International Women’s Day in 2021, when its Twitter account opened a thread about a scholarship scheme for female employees pursuing culinary careers with the line “Women belong in the kitchen”. A follow-up tweet added “If they want to, of course”, but by then the first line had done its work.

The brand apologised and deleted the original tweet that day, citing abusive comments in the thread. KFC Gaming also joined in, posting a meme telling Burger King that the second-best time to delete it was now. Brand expert Allen Adamson told ABC News that a tweet often stands on its own rather than being treated as the start of a conversation, which helps explain why Burger King’s follow-up struggled to undo the first impression.

Liquid Death’s skull cans and Ryanair’s sarcasm both match what people already expect from those brands, whereas a fast-food chain borrowing a line most people know as a sexist cliché had to rely on readers reaching the second tweet before reacting to the first. The scholarship had a real purpose behind it, but the joke arrived before the point did

 

Not Every Controversy Pays Off

 

The brands that seem to have made controversy work each had something solid behind the noise, whether that was a product identity, a personality or a set of values, which gave people a reason to stay once the argument moved on. Some brands caught attention deliberately while others stumble into it and the ones that get something lasting out of it are the ones that already knew what they wanted people to remember.