Businesses are becoming less confident in their ability to survive a major cyber-attack, but the worrying part is that many aren’t doing much to prepare for one either.
New research from business resilience specialists IO has found that just 41% of UK and US cybersecurity managers are very confident their organisations could handle a major cyber incident. That’s a considerable drop from 61% last year, suggesting that businesses are becoming increasingly aware of their vulnerabilities.
However, awareness doesn’t necessarily translate into action. Despite growing concerns about cyber threats, fewer than half of organisations regularly test their incident response plans, while even fewer have a designated incident response team or a documented plan in place.
nd with 71% of organisations surveyed identifying a cyber-attack as the single biggest threat to their ability to continue trading over the next twelve months, the gap between what businesses fear and what they’re actually doing to protect themselves is bigger than many people may realise.
Cybersecurity Confidence Is Falling, But Preparedness Isn’t Improving
IO’s latest “State of Information Security” report, based on research among 3,000 cybersecurity managers and senior professionals in the UK and US, highlights a growing problem with organisational resilience. While confidence in handling a major cyber incident has fallen by 20 percentage points over the past year, the practical foundations needed to manage one remain surprisingly weak.
Only 45% of organisations regularly test their incident response plans. Meanwhile, just 39% have a designated incident response team or individual responsible for managing an incident, and the same proportion have a documented incident response plan.
Testing defences against emerging threats isn’t much better, with only 42% of organisations saying they’ve done so. Now, this is particularly concerning given how quickly the cybersecurity landscape is changing. AI is giving attackers new capabilities, businesses are relying on increasingly complex digital infrastructure and the number of potential entry points into an organisation continues to grow.
In other words, organisations are facing a more complicated threat environment while seemingly struggling to get some of the basics right.
Chris Newton-Smith, CEO of IO, says that organisations aren’t doing enough to address their concerns, despite the growing complexity of the threat landscape. He also points out that incident response plans often lack essential components. On average, the plans examined in the research included fewer than four out of ten common elements, including regular testing, clearly defined responsibilities and communication plans for regulators and customers.
Having a document somewhere outlining what to do during a cyber-attack is one thing. Knowing who is responsible, how to respond and how to communicate when systems are compromised is quite another.
More from Cybersecurity
- Is Cyber Resilience Really A People Problem? What ISF World Congress 2026’s Line-Up Suggests
- One Identity Unveils Safeguard 9.0 For Simpler PAM
- One Identity Unveils Active Roles 8.6 With Enhanced Security And Administration
- OffSec Celebrates 20 Years Of Practitioner-Built Training From The Creators of Kali Linux And OSCP
- How Huntress Is Using Every Cyberattack To Make Small Businesses Safer
- The Value of Free Security Resources Online
- Announced! The Winners Of TechRound’s Cybesecurity40 2026 Are…
- 24. Firewalla
A Cyber Attack Could Mean Days Of Business Disruption
The consequences of being unprepared aren’t simply theoretical; they’re very real, as many companies have had to learn the hard way. According to IO’s research, 83% of organisations that experienced a cybersecurity incident said their worst incident disrupted operations for at least a day. Even more concerning is that 42% of organisations experienced disruption lasting four days or longer.
For businesses that depend on digital systems to process transactions, communicate with customers or deliver services, several days of downtime can be extremely expensive. And what’s more, the financial consequences can also extend well beyond the initial attack.
A quarter of respondents who experienced a cybersecurity or information security incident in the past twelve months said their most significant incident cost between £100,001 and £250,000. Technical remediation and recovery accounted for the largest share of reported incident costs (22%), followed by downtime or lost revenue (17%) and higher insurance premiums after the incident (15%).
These figures demonstrate why cybersecurity preparedness shouldn’t simply be viewed as another IT expense. Indeed, when something goes wrong, the financial impact can reach far beyond the security department.
Businesses Aren’t Planning To Spend More On Cybersecurity
Perhaps one of the more surprising findings is that organisations aren’t necessarily planning to increase spending in some of the areas that could help address these problems. IO found that the proportion of cybersecurity managers expecting spending on incident response and crisis management to increase fell from 61% last year to 50% this year. Similarly, expectations of increased spending on threat intelligence and threat hunting dropped from 67% to 54%.
So, why the contrast? Businesses are becoming less confident about their ability to survive a cyber-attack, yet the appetite for increased investment in some of the very areas that could improve their resilience appears to be weakening. Surely they would want to improve their defences if they’re feeling vulnerable?
Of course, spending more money doesn’t automatically make an organisation more secure. But having the right people, processes and resources in place is essential if businesses want to respond effectively when an incident occurs.
Cybersecurity Is About More Than Preventing An Attack
Ultimately, one of the most important distinctions in IO’s research is between preventing an attack and being able to recover from one. Even organisations that do have sophisticated security systems can experience breaches. The objective shouldn’t simply be to make attacks impossible, but rather to ensure that when something does happen, the business can respond quickly, limit the damage and continue operating.
Newton-Smith argues that resilience needs to be treated as a core part of cybersecurity and governance, rather than as a separate consideration. He highlights developments including the UK’s Cyber Security and Resilience Bill and the Cyber Resilience Pledge as examples of the growing emphasis on taking a more structured approach to managing cyber risk and maintaining operational continuity.
And perhaps that’s where businesses need to start shifting their thinking. Cybersecurity isn’t just about having the latest detection software, investing in AI-powered defences or hoping that attackers choose somebody else. It’s also about knowing exactly what happens when those defences fail. Because being worried doesn’t help at all if companies aren’t willing to pre-empt attacks.
